Two offers, side by side. One pays $5,000 more in base salary. The other has a stronger retirement match, more PTO, and a flexible schedule. Which one actually pays more?
Most people can't answer that question quickly, because most people only compare the one number that's easiest to compare. Here's everything else worth putting on the table.
Retirement Matching
An employer match on retirement contributions is effectively additional compensation — money the employer adds on top of your salary, contingent on you contributing yourself. A strong match can be worth several thousand dollars a year depending on your contribution level, and it's frequently left out of a quick salary comparison entirely.
Bonus Structure
1Guaranteed vs. target
A "target bonus" is not the same as a guaranteed one — ask directly what percentage of employees actually hit target in a typical year, and how the bonus has trended historically.
2Timing
Some bonuses pay out annually, others quarterly, and some require you to still be employed on the payout date — worth knowing before you factor it into your decision, especially if you're weighing a near-term move.
Equity
At a private or early-stage company especially, equity is the compensation component with the widest range of actual eventual value — anywhere from meaningful to effectively zero. Ask about the vesting schedule, the current valuation, and whether there have been past liquidity events. Weight equity conservatively in your decision unless you have real reason for confidence in the company's trajectory.
Paid Time Off and Flexibility
PTO has a real dollar value — a role offering four weeks instead of two is effectively offering additional paid time, even if the base salary is identical. Schedule flexibility, remote or hybrid arrangements, and how strictly they're actually enforced day to day are also worth weighing, particularly if commute time, caregiving responsibilities, or burnout are factors in your decision.
Health Insurance and Other Benefits
Premium costs, deductibles, and coverage quality vary significantly between employers, and a plan with a lower premium but a much higher deductible can end up costing more in a bad year. Also worth checking: professional development budget, tuition reimbursement, parental leave policy, and any other benefit with a real, calculable dollar value.
How to Actually Compare Two Offers
1List every component side by side
Base salary, bonus target, retirement match, estimated equity value, PTO days, and any other benefit with a real dollar value — one column per offer.
2Estimate a rough total for each
It won't be perfectly precise, especially with equity, but a rough total gives a dramatically more accurate picture than comparing base salary figures alone.
This same comparison matters even when you're not choosing between two offers — it's also the right lens for deciding whether a lower-base-salary offer during a career change is actually a smaller cut than it first appears, which we cover in more depth in the companion article on taking a pay cut to change careers.
Mistakes People Make Evaluating an Offer
Comparing only base salary. The single most common mistake, and the one that most distorts an otherwise close decision.
Treating target bonus as guaranteed income. Budgeting around a bonus that may not fully materialize creates real financial risk.
Overvaluing early-stage equity. It's easy to get excited about a number that may never actually be realized.
Ignoring PTO and flexibility entirely. These have a real value and a real impact on quality of life, even without an obvious dollar figure attached.
Never asking clarifying questions before deciding. Vesting schedules, bonus payout timing, and benefit details are all reasonable, expected questions to ask before accepting.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I compare two offers with different mixes of salary and benefits?
Build a simple side-by-side list of every component — base salary, bonus target, equity, retirement match, PTO, and any other benefits with a real dollar value — and estimate a rough total for each offer. It won't be perfectly precise, but it gives a far more accurate comparison than base salary alone.
Is equity worth negotiating for at a smaller or private company?
It can be, but treat it with appropriate caution, since private company equity often carries significant uncertainty around actual future value. Ask specific questions about vesting schedule, current valuation, and any past liquidity events before weighting it heavily in your decision.
Should I prioritize PTO or salary if I can only negotiate one?
It depends entirely on your personal priorities and financial situation — there's no universally correct answer. Someone prioritizing near-term savings or debt payoff may lean toward salary, while someone valuing flexibility or facing burnout may weight PTO or schedule flexibility more heavily.
Weighing an offer? Make sure your resume is ready if you decide to keep looking
Free AI analysis across 5 dimensions — ATS compatibility, keyword match, impact language, formatting, and experience clarity. No signup required.
Score my resume free →